Memory Tricks: Scooter Libby’s Defense

In the April 3 issue of The New Republic, Jason Zengerle writes about Harvard psychology professor Daniel Schacter’s research into the fallibility of memory, summarized in his book, The Seven Sins of Memory.   Professor Schacter is going to testify in Scooter Libby’s defense to explain how any misstatements Libby made to federal investigators could easily have been entirely legitimate memory lapses. 

The TNR article specifically mentions “‘transience,’ the forgetting that occurs with the passage of time,” which can include actual distortion of what’s remembered.

This is relevant to this blog, as regular readers know, because I’m interested in how the vagaries of human memory might well have affected the stories recounted in the Bible.

Comments

2 responses to “Memory Tricks: Scooter Libby’s Defense”

  1. Göran Koch-Swahne Avatar

    Unlettered men have long memories…
    Also, there were memno-techniques in use. Only documents are forged ;=)
    But old men forget…
    And politicians? Well, so far ours are less corrupt.

  2. D. C. Avatar

    Göran Koch-Swahne writes:

    Unlettered men have long memories…

    Granted — but are they accurate memories? A lot of evidence suggests that’s not necessarily the case — which means we have an epistemic problem of determining which memories are accurate. (Litigators must confront this problem every single day.)

    Also, there were memno-techniques in use.

    Presumably you’re saying that in New Testament times, (i) people consciously used memory techniques to improve their recall, and (ii) those techniques were effective. And the reason you believe that to be the case is . . . ? The major and minor inconsistencies in the Gospels suggest that these techniques, if used, weren’t entirely effective.

    But old men forget…

    Yup. Not only do they forget, they remember selectively, and sometimes incorrectly. Of this we have abundant evidence.
    Thanks for stopping by, Göran; nice to see you over here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *